Don’t list cases on Christians before Justice Vaidyanathan

CJ asked to bar Justice Vaidyanathan from certain cases

The judge’s recent comments that Christian educational institutions were highly unsafe for the future of girl children have kicked up a major row.

Sixty-four senior advocates of the Madras High Court on Wednesday petitioned Chief Justice Vijay Tahilramani, asking her not to post any cases relating to Christian missionaries, their institutions and women before Justice S Vaidyanathan.

The judge’s recent comments that Christian educational institutions were “highly unsafe” for the future of girl children have kicked up a major row. The advocates, including senior counsels R Vaigai and Sudha Ramalingam, also asked the Chief Justice to counsel Justice Vaidyanathan to “suo motu” recall the judgement delivered by him on August 16 and delete some more paragraphs that are against women.

The representation by the advocates came a day after the judge agreed to delete the relevant paragraph on Christian institutions from the verdict that was delivered on a petition filed by a professor of the prestigious Madras Christian College (MCC) who is accused of sexually harassing his students during an academic trip to Karnataka early this year.

“There is a general feeling among parents of students, especially female students, that coeducational study in Christian institutions is highly unsafe for the future of their children,” Justice Vaidyanathan had said in his order, which was withdrawn on Tuesday.

In their 7-page representation to the Chief Justice, the advocates pointed to “two sweeping observations” — damning Christian educational institutions and women who complain of violence against them by Justice Vaidyanathan and complained that this was not the first time that the judge was making “unwanted” comments against women.

“It is, therefore, only fair and just that no litigation concerning the above issues (Christian missionaries, their institutions and women) be posted before Justice S Vaidyanathan and in the event such a matter comes up before him, he ought to recuse himself to preserve the appearance of impartiality of the judiciary,” the representation read.

Speaking to DH, senior counsel Vaigai said the judgement has led to horrendous consequences with some right-wing groups even asking for take over of Christian institutions by Hindus.
“Though they have been deleted, the damage has been done. There was no occasion for him to make comments on women in this case. He seems to have deep-rooted suspicion against women,” she said and pointed to Justice Vaidyanathan’s controversial remarks on women while hearing a case relating to dress code in temples in Tamil Nadu.

“How will a woman who faced violence feel confident before Justice Vaidyanathan if he has deep-rooted suspicion against them? We have petitioned the Chief Justice not to post such cases before him,” Vaigai further said, adding that the personal opinion of the Judge find its way into his judicial orders.

Justice Vaidyanathan had made the remarks against Christian institutions and women while refusing to quash a show-cause notice issued to Assistant Professor Samuel Tennyson following the findings of a Committee of Enquiry (Internal Complaints Committee) which probed the sexual harassment complaint against him, and the consequential second show-cause notice to him on May 24, 2019.


Persecution Relief wishes to withhold personal information to protect the victims of Christian Persecution, hence names and places have been changed. Please know that the content and the presentation of views are the personal opinion of the persons involved and do not reflect those of Persecution Relief. Persecution Relief assumes no responsibility or liability for the same. All Media Articles posted on our website, are not edited by Persecution Relief and is reproduced as generated on the respective website. The views expressed are the Authors/Websites own. If you wish to acquire more information, please email us at: or reach us on WhatsApp: +91 9993200020

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *